Does the Philippines need 4 more digital banks?

Written by Kapronasia || September 14 2024

In 2021, Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas (BSP) imposed a three-year moratorium on applications for digital banking licenses so that it would have enough time to monitor the performance of the new online lenders and their impact on the financial system. It will take time for Philippine online banks to get out of the red, and in March, the BSP said that just two of the official digital lenders – which it did not identify – are profitable. It may take five to seven years before the others reach that milestone. Nevertheless, the Philippine central bank is pressing ahead with its plan to allow for more digital banks. From January 1, 2025, four more licensed online lenders will be permitted.

The Philippines currently has six online lenders that have received digital banking licenses: UNO Digital Bank, UnionDigital Bank, GoTyme, Overseas Filipino Bank of state-run Land Bank of the Philippines, Tonik Digital Bank and Maya Bank. In addition, there are other entities that operate as de facto digital banks but face more restrictions than the six licensed lenders.

The reason that the BSP is willing to boost the number of licensed digital banks to 10 is twofold. First, there is sufficient market demand. The Philippines is the second largest market in Southeast Asia after Indonesia, with a population of about 116 million, and like Indonesia it is a vast island nation that is not necessarily conducive to physical bank branches. Second, the Philippine central bank is intent on reaching some financial inclusion and digitization targets in the next few years. With more official online lenders, it can reach those targets faster.

Yet some analysts are circumspect about the introduction of more online lenders when the existing ones are still struggling to turn a profit. To that end, the Philippines current licensed digital banks recorded a combined net loss of 4.1 billion pesos ($72.58 million) in the April-June period, according to the BSP, a significant increase over the 1.3 billion pesos they lost during the same period a year earlier.

The Philippines’ digital banks also have a relatively high non-performing loan (NPL) ratio. According to the BSP, as of May 2024, P4.9 billion of digital banks’ total loan portfolio was considered non-performing — more than 90 days late on a payment — resulting in a gross NPL ratio of almost 21%, compared to the 3.57% ratio for the overall Philippine banking sector.

With the addition of four new digital banks, market competition is bound to intensify. We doubt that this will prompt applicants for the four licenses to innovate dramatically. Instead, we expect that there will be lots of generous customer subsidies offered at the beginning so that the new arrivals can rapidly build up their respective deposit bases – which they must do in order to develop lending products.